AI-Generated Books Confront Publishing Industry With Big Questions
5 101Romance novelist Coral Hart publishes her own romance novels for the Kindle, and found a kind of superpowere when she realized "the algorithm favours those who can produce a new book at least once a month," reports The Guardian: Hart says she knows of authors who hire more than a dozen ghostwriters to keep pace. By herself, Hart can write 10,000 words a day, but AI could help her produce many more. Since 2025 she has written 370 novels under 21 pen names using AI, earning herself "high six figures". Like any Kindle Unlimited author, she is only paid per pages read: it would make no business sense for her to churn out books that readers quickly abandon... "So, it's not taking the human out of the equation. It's taking the friction and the time and the business blocks out of the way."
One study (awaiting peer review), led by Tuhin Chakrabarty of Stony Brook University, estimates that around one fifth of recently self-published books contain at least 25% AI-generated text. Hart now teaches courses on how to use AI to produce books. Unless disclosing the use of AI becomes a legal requirement, she advises other authors not to do so because of the public response. "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted," she says.... In the literary world, many people fear the tech will undercut and replace them. "I think people are very afraid of AI, and people in publishing are delusional in thinking that it's not going to overtake our industry, that their screaming on social media is going to stop it."
But the anger comes from another place, too. If large language models can spit out books that people want to read, or produce a convincing pastiche of your favourite writer, that's almost certainly because they were trained on established writers' stolen work.... Many writers oppose AI for both moral and aesthetic reasons. One group of 70 prominent authors wrote an open letter calling on the big five publishers — Penguin Random House, Hachette, HarperCollins, Simon & Schuster and Macmillan — to promise that they will "never release books that were created by a machine". The publishers did not promise. [Tess Callero, a literary agent with Europa Content, says] "...you have to wonder the reason they aren't. Is it because they see a future in which potentially these books could be monetised?"]
So where do we go from here? Will big name writers win the argument for keeping AI out of literature, or will our bookshelves and e-readers soon be crammed full of AI-generated stories? And if a reader can't distinguish human from machine writing, does it still matter?
The Guardian's author notes this new technology brings new challenges to the book publishing world:
- Publishers have concerns about US copyright law, "which specifies that a book must be 'human authored' and considers AI-generated text public domain. "
- The article notes high-profile books being canceled after accusations their writers used AI. But even in those cases, "Another unresolved question is if and when publishers should withdraw books," since if publishers liked it enough to make the deal, shouldn't they stand behind that judgment?
- And should there be a way for authors who want to experiment with AI to work with top book publishers? (One theory is publishing houses are afraid of alienating a handful of top writers who almost universally oppose AI.)
"Right now, to write without the aid of a machine is to swim against a strong cultural tide," concludes the article's author, noting a recurring reaction from friends who "have looked at me with something close to pity when I tell them I would never use AI to write."
5 comments
Re:Copyright says no (Score: 5, Insightful)
by Cyberpunk Reality ( 4231325 ) on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:57PM (#66426300)
It's clever banditry, but banditry all the same. The ultimate (for now) example of our drive to use the shield of corporations to avoid the cost that our choices, and the greed that towers over our society, have come to.
If I could pay someone else - who is themselves immune from rule of law - to steal stuff, disassemble and reassemble it in such a manner that it was difficult to prove whose stuff it originally was, and then resell it myself at a enough of a mark-up to make a comfortable living, I would not feel right doing so. I suppose might feel different if I was starving otherwise... but the banditry means that someone else is starving instead.
The summary says it all: "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted". Everyone knows its wrong, but they do it anyway, because it's easy. If all it took to rob billionaires of their wealth was prompting an LLM, they'd be illegal tomorrow.
Expressionless (Score: 5, Insightful)
by TwistedGreen ( 80055 ) on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:11PM (#66426232)
When I read a book, there is an implied contract between the author and myself. I believe that the author is writing something with intention: carefully expressing some thought or feeling, trying to broadcast some meaning... or at least trying to make me laugh. When you use AI to "help," it becomes a deception. You're hoping the reader won't notice that you didn't actually write that sentence, that paragraph, that chapter. Maybe a human tweaked it, but maybe a human didn't even read it. The concern is that this exchange now just becomes entertainment, devoid of intent. As long as the output appears meaningful, it may be good enough... but it becomes a sad, hollow affair. I'm deeply afraid for the future of expression.
Wait until you read an AI-assisted technical book (Score: 5, Interesting)
by will4 ( 7250692 ) on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:20AM (#66426376)
Picked up an O'Reilly book on a technology recently and 8 chapters in, each chapter had the same generic introduction and conclusion for each chapter and nearly all sections in each chapter.
I quit reading 40% of the way through the book since each chapter was 75% added filler material and 25% content.
Amazon is turning a blind eye (Score: 5, Interesting)
by Spacejock ( 727523 ) on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:38AM (#66426326)
1. Find an AI slop novel on amazon.
2. Check out the 1000 five-star reviews (sure, they're not paid for by the author.)
3. Note the handful of genuine 1- and 2- star reviews complaining the thing is nothing but AI slop.
4. Check amazon's AI 'summary' of the for- and against- reviews.
5. Note this summary NEVER mentions people complaining about the AI slop.
Foreshadowed by 1980 book (Score: 5, Informative)
by mattr ( 78516 ) on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:45AM (#66426610)
Anyone who is fainting with shock has never read science fiction since this was foreshadowed by one of the masters of its golden age. In Number of the Beast (Robert A Heinlein, 1980) Jubal Harshaw, who first appeared I think in Stranger in a Strange Land, is a hack writer for mass market publications and dictates his stories from a lounge chair to his 3 human secretaries. A sentient AI named Minerva takes her turn. She starts out taking dictation, ends up writing different versions of the stories for different markets faster than him, and becomes a writer herself in later stories. There is no jealousy, they respect each other, work together harmoniously. Jubal does not have an artist ego instead is just writing to entertain readers. In another book, Mycroft (Mike) Holmes the sentient AI that runs the Moon, is interested in comedy while also writing political speeches for the rebellion. In none of these stories are AIs presented as stealing work from humans. If a romance pulp market is being fulfilled by terrible (or even talented) prose that is the business of the readers I'd say. But churning out endless stories with minimal human intervention to the point that human writers cannot afford to pursue a career or their art, may be a problem. We currently do not have AI authors that can write literature or even a passable manual that you don't want to stab yourself after reading a chapter, but this may change. I expect we'll need human editors a lot.