Is Mandating AI Use in the Workplace Backfiring?
4 76Some workplaces are holding mandatory AI training sessions, while others "are requiring employees to use a specific number of tokens," reports the Washington Post, "or log a certain amount of time on AI platforms."
The article's headline? "Why mandating AI use in the workplace can backfire." [A] lot of employers are going about it the wrong way, said Arvind Karunakaran, an assistant professor of management science and engineering at Stanford University. "You can consume a lot of tokens without creating a lot of value," Karunakaran said....
The adoption of AI is happening faster than the adoption of the internet did, according to a new report from Stanford's Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence. And many users report that AI tools have really helped — whether saving time and costs or increasing innovation. The same report, though, found that one-third of organizations surveyed expected AI-related staff reductions in the coming year. Especially in that context, simply mandating usage won't spark excitement about the technology, Karunakaran said, and neither will insisting that employees use AI to cut turnaround times and ramp up productivity. "People start asking questions like 'What am I as an employee getting out of it?'" he said.
The report he co-authored found that in the short-term, mandating AI tools may ramp up productivity. But in the long-to-medium term, employees tend to feel devalued and disengaged. From there, people find ways to mindlessly check the box.
When employers present these tools and their use as an opportunity for employees to expand their skills and grow their careers, people are much likelier to use them, Karunakaran said. He suggests that rather than requiring employees use a specific number of tokens, companies should encourage workers to experiment and share their own use cases and success stories. Most workplaces are still shutting employees out of the conversation. More than half of employees said they have less of a say than they'd want on adopting new tech at work, according to a report from Gallup and Jobs for the Future, a work and education nonprofit.
Any Slashdot readers want to share your own stories on how AI was introduced at your workplace?
4 comments
"present as an opportunity" (Score: 5, Insightful)
by ffkom ( 3519199 ) on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:07PM (#66414543)
When employers present these tools and their use as an opportunity for employees to expand their skills and grow their careers...
... those employers would just be lying, and many employees would see through this.
There is little "skill" in asking some AI agent to do something, and even if some employee meticulously formulates his prompts to optimize the effective use of the AI, this will go unnoticed by his supervisors, while at the same time a lot of general thinking skills shrink among the entirety of the population due to the outsourcing of thinking to AIs. The only growth their careers will see is a growth in free time due to unemployment or a growth in unpleasant physical work at minimum wage for those filling that gap until the robots get good enough also in physical work.
Re:Working as intended (Score: 5, Insightful)
by ffkom ( 3519199 ) on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:42PM (#66414587)
Humans invented machines to do their work so they would have more free time.
Yes, and that is a good thing as long as humans own the machines that do their work. This time, however, humans do not own the machines that do their work, and their unemployment is a problem, because the machine owners have no reason to keep the no longer needed humans around (or even alive).
A waste of time (Score: 5, Interesting)
by uncoveror ( 570620 ) on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:37PM (#66414579)
I work in IT Support at a federal agency. They have crammed IT into our ticketing system which is a tweaked version of ServiceNow. Its search tool drifts off topic faster than a conventional search engine, and if we let it write the conclusion section of our tickets, we have to do them over because they do not reflect the work that was done in order at all. AI complicates simple tasks and wastes time. That is the opposite of what computers are for.
Just the Hawthorne Effect? (Score: 5, Interesting)
by SoftwareArtist ( 1472499 ) on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:44PM (#66414651)
The report he co-authored found that in the short-term, mandating AI tools may ramp up productivity.
The Hawthorne Effect [wikipedia.org] is based on a series of experiments in the 1920s and 30s. They tried varying lots of aspects of a work environment to see how it affected productivity, like lighting levels, break schedules, and whether workers were given snacks. They found that just about any change led to an increase in productivity, but only for a short time. Then it went back to where it started. The particular change didn't really matter, only that you changed something, and that people knew they were being studied.
This report is likely something similar. If you make people work differently, for a short time they become more engaged. They may also be focused on proving to their manager they can use the new technology. But it doesn't last. Productivity drops again. It's a mistake to assume the effect had anything to do with the particular change you made.