The New York Times Sues Brave Web Browser For AI Scraping, Bypassing Paywalls
5 93The New York Times and several other publishers have sued (PDF) Brave Software, accusing the browser maker of scraping their websites without permission and helping users bypass paywalls. The Verge reports: According to a complaint (PDF) filed by the companies that run New York Daily News, the Chicago Tribune, and the Orlando Sentinel, Brave Software has monetized its index of scraped websites by, in part, providing AI companies with paid access to "real-time online content from the Brave Index." The AI companies then use that index to train their models, access content to "respond to specific user queries," or both. Brave has allegedly provided "stolen copyrighted content" to "many" AI companies including Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere. Brave also promotes "hundreds of top publishers" as being accessible through its "Paywall blocker" feature in its browser.
"Brave has never asked for the Publishers' permission to access their websites, much less to copy the material and provide it to users or other AI companies," the complaint says. "On the contrary, as noted above, Brave allows its users to bypass the Publishers' paywalls without their consent, and has taken other steps that prevent the Publishers from blocking Brave's access to the Publishers' websites. Brave has never compensated the Publishers for the unlawful use, copying, and distribution of the Publishers' copyrighted content." "While we believe in the ethical and responsible use and development of AI, Brave has flouted established copyright law and ignored repeated requests by The Times to stop its infringing conduct," Graham James, an NYT spokesperson, says in a statement. "We filed this lawsuit to hold Brave accountable for stealing our content to power its own products and to provide it to some of the most prominent and well resourced generative AI companies in the world."
5 comments
Re:I use Firefox (Score: 5, Interesting)
by Himmy32 ( 650060 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @02:17PM (#66406433)
And unsurprisingly the New York Times isn't super worried about the tiny segment of population bypassing through sketchy Russian sites. But the whole market lost billions of dollars last week because of how much money AI answers are sucking out of advertising and subscriptions. Google lost half of a trillion dollars in value. That's big enough of an issue to generate lawsuits.
All of this is unsurprising as the the value proposition for Brave from the start was removing the monetization strategies of content makers. At some point someone needs to pay either with subscriptions or advertising eyeball time.
Unfortunate that Brave Search will also be affected as the "Brave Index" powers both the API for LLMs and the search engine, which is one of the few that the results haven't been slowly getting worse.
Re:Screw the New York Times (Score: 5, Informative)
by hierofalcon ( 1233282 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @04:07PM (#66406629)
I don't have a problem with digital distribution of news. I subscribed to the print WSJ for a very long time. But with our wonderful US mail service, the print edition would arrive in batches, days late. It became worthless. So I switched to digital once monitors got a high enough resolution that I could read the print edition in digital format. I still skip the ads. It's even faster to right arrow over full page ads now than to turn a page manually, and it's available first thing in the morning instead of when I get off work and already stale by a day or more depending on the US mail. So I'm a fan of digital news.
But the WSJ exists because of their content and price points. A bloomberg terminal is out of my price range. The WSJ is okay for budget conscious people. If it had a comics page I'd be even happier. And I suspect that providing some of their content to the world - say a few articles a month - doesn't hurt them much. A bundle with IBD and Barron's is pretty reasonable.
But I gave up on the local paper quite a while ago. Too little local news coverage, and anything important was going to be in the WSJ anyway. And their subscription price for a year was higher than WSJ.
I suppose there are a few columnists in the NYT or daily that people don't think they can live without, but it is really about content for every newspaper. If you provide timely content that is unique and worthwhile, people will pay for a subscription. If you don't, or are just one of many AP or other news feed suppliers, you shouldn't be surprised when nobody wants to subscribe. But it is also largely about reputation. People aren't going to sign up for a subscription or expose an e-mail address just to view an article. If you are worthwhile, people will subscribe on their own. But they aren't likely to subscribe to some unknown paper (or even a well known paper like the NYT) if they don't need it for local news. I live a long way from NYC. I might read an article if it was free, but I have no interest in paying a subscription price for all the NYC local content that doesn't matter to me.
Re:Screw the New York Times (Score: 5, Informative)
by SomePoorSchmuck ( 183775 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @05:32PM (#66406843)
They sold advertising space on the make believe notion that x number of eyeballs saw every ad. It was always bogus.
No, they didn't.
At no point did anyone in publishing/advertising believe that putting a 3-inch single column ad in the Lifestyle & Arts section F of a newspaper with a circulation of 347,000 meant that the ad was seen by 347,000 different people. The fact that you personally may have never looked at ads (which, if you're being honest, is almost certainly not true unless you were born after 1990ish) doesn't matter. Everyone in publishing/advertising understood that they weren't getting 347,000 "pageviews" - they were making sure that their ad had a high chance of being seen/noticed by the percentage of readers who see/notice ads. And up until 2005-2010, that was still a large percentage.
Back before ~2010, and especially once you go back to 1960-2000, Americans deliberately, voluntarily, looked at advertisements in newspapers and magazines because that was how you found out what stores were out there, what the stores sold, what current prices were. It was common for people to dellberately flip through the inserts for stores like Sears, Montgomery Ward, JCPenney, Dillards, Kmart, WalMart, REI, Circuit City, Best Buy, as well as all the inserts and wrappers for local grocery stores, car dealerships, real estate listings, garage sale listings, movie theatre showtimes, on and on.
Ads were a normal, accepted part of the socioeconomic biome. It sounds wild now, but we used to live in harmony with them. When you didn't care about them you could easily ignore them. When you cared about them - and every adult at some point did care about them, to buy a car, a refrigerator, rent an apartment, find the lowest price on brisket, get the Domino's pizza coupons for this week's big game - you could easily find them and were glad they existed.
The modern seething revulsion toward advertising is a creation of the Internet, where ads escaped ecological equilibrium and evolved into invasive species which consume every possible space alongside the content and, when that space was not enough, the content itself became an ad - "I built this AI agent that lowered my car insurance by $130 month and you can too! Link in bio."
Nor were all ads the same. Which section, where on the page, sizing, layout, full color, section wrappers, extra inserts, etc. all had different costs. When ads weren't invasive - when they just sat there on a page rather than popup, flash, wiggle, trigger effects when your mouse happened to hover over, autoplay sound, autoplay video, drive-by download malware, etc.etc - you saw the ads that might matter to you, organically. If you didn't need to buy a car and didn't find cars interesting, you never opened the Automotive section of the paper, so none of those ads were ever seen by you. But those who were into cars or were in the market for a car, did look at that section and did see those ads. Same for people who were or were not interested in art galleries, the symphony, cultural festivals, cinema.
It's quite ironic that the aggressive targetmaxxing of Google and the other major Internet advertising companies - by insisting on chasing the reader down and holding our eyeballs open and showing us a constant stream of ads based on a phrase we used one time in a discussion board post somewhere - have actually decreased the variety and relevance of the ads we see. Because instead of it being an organic ecosystem where we see the ads we need when we naturally would want to see them, we now desperately wish to avoid seeing any ads, anywhere, at any time, under any circumstances. Even when they might actually be relevant - indeed, the targeted intrusiveness is often what we resent most, nowadays.
Big guy going after the little guy - precedent (Score: 5, Insightful)
by Puls4r ( 724907 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @02:20PM (#66406439)
This is classic "big guy" going after the "little guy" in the hopes that they can use their money and clout to financially bury Brave. And when they manage to do it, they've set a precedent they can use in other court cases. Fuck the New York Times. Fuck their new "fair and balanced" bullshit. Direct quote from them: "expand its coverage of conservative viewpoints"
I see this as 2 different issues (Score: 5, Insightful)
by dirk ( 87083 ) on <dirk@one.net> on Monday November 02, 2026 @03:17PM (#66406553)
The first issue is if the only thing it takes to get around these sites paywalls is disabling some scripts, then they don't have a paywall at all. There are ways to put your content behind a paywall so it cannot be accessed (see porn sites). If they are just running a script to stop you, then I have no issue with Brave disabling that script to allow users to run the page without it. Sorry NYT, get a better paywall.
The second issue is the bigger one. If they are truly accessing these sites and scaping the data and offering it to other companies, that is an entirely different thing. That is basically taking the content and redistributing it, which is a huge deal. I would side with the NYT on that one.