Itch Is Being Flooded By AI-Generated Garbage
4 66The number of game pages being created per-day on Itch has doubled, the indie games site announced Saturday on Bluesky. When asked why, they responded: "take a guess."
As the gaming news site Aftermath puts it, "the surge has been almost entirely down to AI-created garbage racing onto the platform as the popularity of vibe-coded theft, copycats and machine-built slop explodes." Back in 2024, when the spectre of AI-'created' video games was still in its infancy, indie platform itch.io decided that the best it could do to combat this growing threat was, like Valve has done with Steam, institute a voluntary 'AI' filter when adding new projects to the site. By November 2026, as itch buckles under the weight of new AI-generated 'games' pouring onto the site, that filter is proving about as robust as a wet paper bag.... Shopfronts are being deluged by this shit, and it's making it a terrible user experience for customers.
And while in Valve's case there's a compelling case for stronger human moderation of the store, I'm not sure that's a viable option for a relatively tiny, community-run platform like itch... [A]t time of writing I visited the latest releases section and there was still a huge number of clearly AI-generated titles (or titles making extensive use of AI in their visual assets) which made no use of itch's voluntary tag system.
The issue here isn't that these games are making money--itch themselves say in a reply that while the number of projects listed has doubled, "the number of downloads and purchases has not"--it's that an inability to combat this surge makes the site worse for every single person using it. It gets harder to find real games, for example, and it also makes the shopfront look like a clearance rack.
4 comments
Re:Everything is now (Score: 5, Insightful)
by stealth_finger ( 1809752 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @08:56AM (#66405839)
No, because slop is what it is.
Gatekeeping (Score: 5, Interesting)
by sourcerror ( 1718066 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @08:06AM (#66405773)
The whole schtick of Itch.io was that it had less gatekeeping than Steam, so if Steam has an issue with the flood of AI slop, Itch has an even bigger issue.
Re:I'm not so sure (Score: 5, Insightful)
by FictionPimp ( 712802 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @09:32AM (#66405895)
Using AI is a wide spectrum.
You can easily use AI to make great video games, just like you can use AI to write any other software. Just like you can use intellisense for code completion and still make great video games.
The thing that determines if a product is great is the people involved in the process who understand the business case, the expected work product, and the spirit of the goal. So I'm 100% for a game company using AI to help it write code and create the building blocks of a game. Like any product code needs reviews, graphics need tweaked, the software needs to be tested and product tested.
So yes, if you one shot a game with AI and do no testing or tweaking it's going to be shit. If you use it appropriately like any other tool you can accelerate your deliverable and make fine products.
I think we will see some games crafted with love that leveraged AI for the parts that are less interesting. For example someone with talent in graphic design and writing who has a wonderful idea for a turn based RPG, but isn't sure how to make Unity work leverages AI to turn that story and art into something fun. It would be great if everyone could find people who believed in their ideas and worked with them, but often all you find are people who tell you nothing will work. Sometimes you have to go it alone and AI is making that easier.
You can't put it back in a bottle. (Score: 5, Insightful)
by FictionPimp ( 712802 ) on Monday November 02, 2026 @09:07AM (#66405857)
Software development as we know it is ending. AI tools are 'good enough' that any idea can be made fairly quickly with even limited knowledge. This opens up a lot of opportunities for creativity and itch scratching while at the same time impacting the commercial value of software. I'm shocked the open source community doesn't see this as a pivital moment for free software.
For example, recently I wanted to play nethack on my m1 mac. I also wanted to use a tileset. Finding no good OSX arm based clients, I spun one up in a week with a custom tileset that I tweaked to my likings and even added graphical features to represent the true 'size' of items and creatures in the game.
Now I'm fully capable of building that solution by hand, it would have taken a month or two, but I would have needed to find a like minded person who knows how to build graphics and shared the same visual inspirations and goals I had. That would have probably just caused me to end the idea. Instead I scratched that itch and have been playing nethack a ton more and I'm happy. I released the code as open source so anyone who cares to can play with it.
To me that is real value and not 'slop'.