'Please Let the Internet Die'
18 198Slashdot reader fjo3 shares an article from Wired: The internet must be put out of its misery. Any rational observer can admit that the current iteration of the web -- and the social fabric woven there -- is not what they signed up for. Symptoms of advanced cultural decay can no longer be ignored. This thing is eating itself. Giants including Meta and Google have been forced to settle massive consumer lawsuits brought over privacy violations and mental health harms allegedly caused by the addictive mechanisms of their platforms. Schools are banning smartphones as multiple countries institute social media restrictions for under-16s. Parents are in a panic about their kids aspiring to careers as social media celebrities, losing themselves in a vast ecosystem of online casinos, or joining extremist movements. Generative AI, briefly considered an amusing novelty, is now a turbocharged slop engine for the web, filling feeds and comment sections with useless, grotesque content. As humans scroll past headlines about AI taking their jobs, confusing fantasy for reality, and contributing to cognitive decline, any consumer appeal the technology might have is turning to anguish. The data centers that power it have become increasingly unpopular, and politically radioactive.
To be online, many now admit, is to be endlessly manipulated and exploited. In December, Oxford University Press declared rage bait to be the word of the year, noting that use of the term had tripled over the previous 12 months. The lexical spike represented a heightened awareness that monetized social accounts churn out bad-faith takes and extremist content, automating this abusive behavior with generative AI, simply to profit off hostile engagement. Billionaire oligarchs have opened the floodgates to such inauthentic activity, conspiracy-mongering, and hate speech by rolling back moderation. In short, when you hang around online in 2026, you see little worth saving. Perhaps a decade ago, you felt that the glimmers of community and joy, of artistic and intellectual exchange, were enough to balance out the toxic junk. No longer.
18 comments
Re:Self described article (Score: 5, Interesting)
by Anonymous Coward ( None ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:19AM (#66399578)
A weak attempt to vilify free speech
It's not free if everyone can't make it. Curated by janitors with particular agendas doesn't qualify as "free".
Re:Self described article (Score: 5, Informative)
by Anonymous Coward ( None ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:33AM (#66399606)
Billionaires do most of the censorship in this world.
citation:
Jeff Bezos: Owns The Washington Post.
Rupert Murdoch (and family): Controls News Corp, which owns The Wall Street Journal, the New York Post, The Times (London), and The Sun.
Patrick Soon-Shiong: Owns the Los Angeles Times and The San Diego Union-Tribune.
John W. Henry: Owns The Boston Globe.
Michael Bloomberg: Owns Bloomberg News and Bloomberg Businessweek.
Marc Benioff: Owns Time magazine.
Laurene Powell Jobs: Owns a majority stake in The Atlantic.
The Newhouse Family (Advance Publications): Owns Condé Nast (including publications like The New Yorker, Vogue, and Vanity Fair)
Re:Self described article (Score: 5, Insightful)
by dfghjk ( 711126 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:56AM (#66399664)
You'd have more credibility if you understood that censorship doesn't apply to reading, it applies to writing.
"I don't read any of them, so I am not censored by them."
Fabulous.
Re:Self described article (Score: 5, Insightful)
by butt0nm4n ( 1736412 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:36AM (#66399610)
A lot of free speech is shit speech as you demonstrate. Knee jerk, emotional and tribal reactions, your ego wanking into a bucket. You had a bad day, go rant at people on the internet and call it an abuse of free speech if you get called an asshole or get cancelled.
Freedom is chaos without some sense of personal responsibility. When you can publish anonymously any bollocks you wouldn't say to someone's face in the street, bereft of any courage, accountability or responsibility, that's a perversion of free speech, how humans have communicated since the start of civilisation. It's not free speech, it's graffitti.
Shit free speech, and that's what it is, shit, where no one is prepared to stand by their words, left us wide open to the destruction of our institutions of trust, they weren't perfect, but they were better than no trust at all, and that is where shit speech has brought us to, total mistrust, prey to any shill with the means to shout loudest.
Re:Waaaah! More censorship! Waaaaaaaaaa! (Score: 5, Interesting)
by zeeky boogy doog ( 8381659 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @03:34PM (#66400198)
The cure for speech you don't like is your own speech against it,
This works in normal life:
A> yay hitler
B, C, D> fuck you nazi piece of shit
onlookers E-Z> wow nobody likes A, I shouldn't be a nazi
But it explicitly does not work when the Social Cancer algorithm is in control:
A> yay hitler
B, C, D> fuck you nazi piece of shit
Social Cancer algorithm: "Wow, A really got a lot of engagement on that post, let's push it to more people."
random people E-Z: "huh, this nazi guy seems to get a lot of attention...
Just like bad money pushes out good and lies spread faster than the truth, negative garbage content pushes out good because we've introduced a curator who is a sociopath that was never taught the difference between good and bad attention. To give a concrete example: There is an entire industrial scale operation that revolves around posting fucktarded "hack" videos to youtube because it doesn't matter if you're posting "this is a bullshit hack because [obvious things]", you still clicked on it and engaged with it and that's all the Social Cancer algorithm cares about.
Forget censorship, I just want to go back to the world where shouting bad shit down means it's shouted down, not actively promoted.
Blame the correct thing (Score: 5, Informative)
by LondoMollari ( 172563 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:09AM (#66399556)
"The Internet" is not Meta and Google or whatever company we are talking about today. "The Internet" is not social media. The Internet is an interconnected network of servers and clients and other devices speaking a range of protocols but mostly TCP/IP and UDP, that communicate with one another. Should the interconnect die? No.
Should the bloodsucking companies manipulating people be punished? Yes, and this has just begun. It won't be enough for some people and others will say "buyer beware." But either way the headline is false and "The Internet" is a necessary communication medium.
Stop confusing social media and commercial services with "the Internet."
Re: Blame the correct thing (Score: 5, Interesting)
by RazorSharp ( 1418697 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @01:26PM (#66399938)
Your comment is 100 years out of date. It is no different than when you morons deny climate science with a straight face. We are living it now and you are telling us not to trust our lying eyes.
Yep, this. (Score: 5, Insightful)
by Brain-Fu ( 1274756 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:38AM (#66399616)
People who don't like the toxicity of social media can stop using it. Problem solved, next!
People who don't like AI slop filling up news articles can switch to a different news source (or, heaven forbid, create one of their own!). Problem solved, next!
If you agree that kids shouldn't have cell phones during school due to the distractions, and that social media is harmful to kids, then what's the problem here? Looks like "the world" is taking appropriate action on that front already. Problem being solved, next!
I think there *is* a greater problem in that huge numbers of people aren't recognizing this and remain caught-up in the toxicity and misinformation and radicalization and etc. that is going on online, and their poor judgment is motivating them to take actions that are harmful, to themselves and others, politically and economically. That problem has me concerned, but we aren't going to fix it by killing the Internet.
Re:Blame the correct thing (Score: 5, Insightful)
by GoJays ( 1793832 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:58AM (#66399668)
Exactly. The internet is not the problem. The problem is the walled gardens that have been setup by social media giants. These networks are not for your benefit, they are there to influence, manipulate, and control... yet some people deem them "essential". Using social media is a choice, not a life requirement. If you don't like social media, don't use it. If you don't like what some newspaper is writing, don't read it. Some people need to take some personal accountability for their choices, or lack there of.
I left social media around the beginning of the pandemic because that is when the crazy's went wild. Instead of letting their manipulative poison and propaganda mess with my mind, I checked out. No, I am not right or left wing... I'm just a person who doesn't want to be drowning in crazy talk by people who are clearly unhinged.
Re: Blame the correct thing (Score: 5, Informative)
by drinkypoo ( 153816 ) on <drink@hyperlogos.org> on Thursday October 29, 2026 @03:42PM (#66400226)
The literal actual backbone of the Internet can be identified because the companies which provide it are literally called backbone providers and the links in question are literally called backbone links. HTH, HAND
Jon Katz, is that you? (Score: 5, Funny)
by mccalli ( 323026 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:10AM (#66399558)
Spirits walk among us.
Re:What is "the internet" (Score: 5, Insightful)
by dfghjk ( 711126 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @11:17AM (#66399698)
I don't know who you think "we" is, but I certainly understand that, the problem is that the OP doesn't. "The internet" here means what a layperson thinks, it is the content not the nuts and bolts. The internet is what you interact with, not the phone line you use to do so. No one advocates that data services should die.
"We just want web 1.0 back"
No, we don't. Ignorance is what has created the mess, it will not be the solution to it. Your opinion is based on your assumed personal superiority, an assumption at odds with your simplistic view.
There is no accountability on the internet, by design. Until that changes, "the internet" will be corrupt and "we", as in you, continue to think that's the right answer. Web 1.0 had no accountability, that was the part preserved to enable the corruption we face.
I have been saying these things since the 90's, for at least 30 years. Greed and corruption was apparent then, all that has changed is how obvious the social damage is. Back then, the enthusiasm was directed to how to exploit ad revenue devices to take money while providing no product or service, literally pure greed. That was what drove the internet then and drives the internet now, a return to "Web 1.0" does nothing to fix that even if it makes you feel better about yourself.
It should also be understood that it's not just "the internet". The computer revolution was driven by opportunities to improve productivity, people was interested because they cared what they could do. Computers and applications were driven by improved capability and that's what computer sciences focused on. That is not true today, instead computing is oriented around exploitation and corporate profit and that is now what computer sciences focus on. That's why modern software development sucks, it's entirely greed-driven. AI is the same, research used to focus on capability, now it's money grab.
Agree, we started with villages (Score: 5, Interesting)
by butt0nm4n ( 1736412 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:16AM (#66399576)
With social media, what they perhaps mean by "internet", we tried to start with a global city and it turned out to be a tower of babble.
We proved to be not evolved enough to deal with a community that size. Anyone who says they like it as it is, is invested in the present chaos.
Start again with villages, little social networks, deciding what they want to let in and getting paid to be advertised to, if they choose to be.
If you want to build that, I can write the spec. The objective is a decentralised cooperative.
Let the roads die... (Score: 5, Insightful)
by pla ( 258480 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:32AM (#66399602)
...Nothing on them but cranky bastards contributing to climate change while moving between ticky-tacky, 40+ hours of indentured servitude, and temples to Mammon.
I largely agree with most of Klee's points, but there's a serious bias issue with his conclusion: "The internet" is just the road we use to get somewhere. Where we go is up to us most of the time. And in this case, the "old internet" is still mostly there - Case in point, I still have a crappy static personal website up that hasn't been updated since the 1990s.
Problem is, nobody wants to read my ramblings from 30 years ago any more than they did 30 years ago. People want FAANGs, even while they may openly resent those same platforms. Sure, Amazon is evil... But the alternative is leaving the house and going to a store, eew! NetFlix kills everything good after two seasons, but two seasons on-demand beats a 30-second stick-figure animation that takes six weeks per "episode" and depends on the unpaid hobbyist creator not getting bored with the project. TikTok is measurably destroying the attention spans of our youth, but we can't risk missing the next big "hold my beer and watch this" moment.
The problem isn't "the internet". The problem is us as a collective whole. When there's demand for trash, sanitation engineers flip to supply side.
Now for the serious post... amend the title (Score: 5, Insightful)
by Akardam ( 186995 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @10:50AM (#66399654)
I would amend the title to: "Please let the way that most people use the internet die".
And that has to start with individuals.
Are you ready to give up social media and clutivate a local group of like-minded friends who will put in the time and effort to socialize in-person?
Are you ready to shop locally for everything you can, and not order online unless you have to?
Are you ready to walk or drive yourself to your favorite local restaurant to pick up your takeout, instead of using a gig delivery service?
Are you ready to eschew LLMs, even to the point of pushing back on your employer if they insist you incorporate LLM output in your work?
The punchline to my little ol' rant here is that I feel most people are too comfortable with, or too addicted to, or whatever to, the kind of things I mention above, and that for most people, if they think about it at all, might have a passing thought of "why should I bother, some other activist will start the fight and then I'll just like their posts".
Boo hoo (Score: 5, Insightful)
by RogueWarrior65 ( 678876 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @11:13AM (#66399692)
Oh, boo hoo! The government can't control what people people see, read, or think. Psst... that's called freedom, son. You should try it some time.
So be a fucking grownup and walk away. (Score: 5, Insightful)
by argStyopa ( 232550 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @11:14AM (#66399694)
TSIA
If you're upset about "everything":
a) take your ritalin or prozac or whatever cocktail of anxiety meds you're on; you missed a dose.
b) you control you. Nobody MAKES you addicted to the social media feeds; yes, absolutely they are CRAFTED to be the visual-cortex version of heroin. I get that, they are meant to be addictive as fuck. NEVERTHELESS you are (supposedly) a human with agency. Just. Put. The. Fucking. Thing. Down. Go for a walk. Read a book. Turn off your router for a while, if that helps.
Otherwise you're just a herd mammal bleating that you don't like the pasture YOU put yourself in.
Shaking fist at clouds? (Score: 5, Interesting)
by King_TJ ( 85913 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @11:53AM (#66399764)
I'm old enough to remember the computer bulletin board system (BBS) days fondly. I ran my own BBS for over a decade, in one form or another. At the end, I moved it to kind of a hybrid setup where I had 4 dial-in phone numbers for modems, but also a 128K ISDN circuit to the Internet. Most callers used it as a way to access some Internet resources while others started connecting to the BBS itself via the Internet.
Ultimately, BBS sysops (the jargon for system operators) realized we were at the end of an era. The Internet simply made the hobby of BBSing obsolete. Why limit oneself to using a specific bulletin board system and whatever limited options it has on its menus, when a raw Internet connection allowed hopping all over the world to content of all types -- even accessing multiple screens of it simultaneously?
Even back then though? I think many of us mourned the lack of personal connection that caused. On a BBS you used regularly, you had typically 100-500 or so somewhat regular users to interact with. Most were in your same geographic location. It wasn't uncommon to organize gatherings so people could meet the real humans behind the screen names/handles.Message topics were more relevant to where you lived. People could actually request 1 on one chats with the sysops, and most people got to know them pretty well.
The Internet doesn't "need to die", but maybe more people should make the effort to seek out and use web sites offering quality content, vs a habit of spending most of their time on big-name social media sites? I know for me, a good example for this is cars. I've always been kind of an auto enthusiast, and I used to always seek out a web message forum for any vehicle I purchased, and immediately join as as new member there. These days, I see all these enthusiast type groups popping up on Facebook -- but none of them offer the depth of information the dedicated web forums have. You just wind up with thousands of people in the Facebook group asking the same questions and wanting to show off photos of whatever they did cosmetically to their ride. The message forums always seem to have a few regulars who REALLY know the car inside and out. I'm talking master mechanics who have taken the whole vehicle apart and put it back together again, in their own garage. And they post a LOT of "how to" type message threads and more.