Google Struggling to Make AI Mode Searches Pay
6 96Alphabet shares fell nearly 10% after Google disclosed that searches through its AI Mode generate less revenue than traditional search, even as overall search revenue grew 12% year over year to $63.25 billion. The Register reports: Alphabet on Wednesday reported its Q3 results, which included news that its year-over-year search query growth rate is the highest it's been in the last five years. Some of that growth comes from users adopting "AI Mode" -- Google's latest LLM-powered search system. Google's revenue from search rose 12 percent year-over-year to $63.25 billion, a little lower than the 14.5 percent growth the company reported in last year's Q3.
During Alphabet's earnings call, chief business officer Philipp Schindler said the slowdown was caused by "lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode." That's a worry given that Google is spending enormous sums on infrastructure. $51.4 billion went out the door in Q3, around two thirds of it going towards servers and networking equipment. The rest funded datacenter builds. That spending appears to have impacted profitability, as Alphabet reported $26.17 billion net income for the quarter. Last year's Q3, during which Google revenue was $102.35 billion, produced $35 billion net income.
Schindler argued that AI search will pay off. "On AI Mode, many of these queries are upper funnel queries, allowing us to capture new, high-value commercial intent," he told investors. "In addition, the majority of AI Mode queries are incremental, creating more monetization opportunities over time." Google tried to seize one of those opportunities today, by turning on ads alongside AI Mode searches around the world, after first testing them in the US only. But for now, AI Mode searches aren't as lucrative as Google's existing search business, which brought in just under half of Alphabet's $125.8 billion quarterly revenue.
6 comments
Re: Is any company managing to make AI anything pa (Score: 5, Interesting)
by commodore73 ( 967172 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @06:50AM (#66399266)
Maybe they haven't figured it out yet, but of the big techs, google honestly seems best positioned to both fund it from other revenues and to figure out how to monetize it without doing stupid shit like the zucker. And they can likely bring the cost down more effectively than especially the frontier models. I wouldn't sell my GOOG just yet. Otherwise, it would likely already be in the google graveyard.
Re: Is any company managing to make AI anything pa (Score: 5, Insightful)
by DarkOx ( 621550 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @08:06AM (#66399366)
I agree
The winners here are going to be people with actual hardware IP (Nvidia, Apple, others), people with actual hardware fabs, and likely Google and Meta. I predict despite the current crazy valuations the Magnificent-7 eventually end up acquiring the leading AI labs.
The real costs are in building models, not hosting them comparatively speaking and that picture only improves as the energy infrastructure and hardware markets gradually align to the volume demands. The labs are already just reselling the hyperscallers computer, there is no reason those guys are not going to take 'good enough' models and beat them on price.
Having the 'best' models is an asset someone with existing SaaS, Marketing, etc business on the hand can leverage and by extension justify the expense. That is why I see OpenAI and Anthropic eventually becoming acquisition targets once the gold-rush investors capitulate on their valuations.
The option is for them to get directly into the datacenter biz (not contracting for them and agreeing consumption commitments but actually building them and owning the dirt all they way up to the roof top chillers. Anthropic seems to be trying to make that play but I still don't know where the revenue will really come from...
Re:Is any company managing to make AI anything pay (Score: 5, Insightful)
by Smidge204 ( 605297 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @07:32AM (#66399322)
Are you sure? There's so much money tied up in circular loans and IOUs based on potential profits that I'm not sure they are.
For example: NVidia invests billions into OpenAI and Anthropic, who then use that money to buy NVidia products. Has NVidia actually made any money, or does the "demand" for the product simply drive up the speculative stock price?
=Smidge=
Search engine company can't do search (Score: 5, Informative)
by Arrogant-Bastard ( 141720 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @06:52AM (#66399270)
They had one job, many years ago, and at the time, they did it rather well. Now they can't do anything well: they've turned their search into AI slop (use DuckDuckGo or StartPage instead), Gmail is one of the world's top spam sources, Google Groups is garbage, their cloud outages keep increasing in severity and frequency, they've killed off too many projects/services to count, and their CEO is a fascist thug who kneels before Trump and obeys his every command.
If any part of your computing practice or operation depends on Google, it's time to move somewhere else.
Amusingly (Score: 5, Interesting)
by Zak3056 ( 69287 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @07:34AM (#66399328)
If you ask Gemini why Google's search results have gotten so bad, it will give you an honest answer and suggest you use DuckDuckGo instead. Not exactly sure how you monetize "our service is telling our customers to go to our competitors instead" unless you're Macy's and you're in a Christmas movie.
Take that, stupid golden goose! (Score: 5, Insightful)
by pla ( 258480 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @09:36AM (#66399476)
The primary reason companies advertise with Google is to drive search results to their site.
If AI summaries become good enough that nobody needs to click the links anymore - What are advertisers paying for? "Brand recognition" only takes things so far, at some point they need real customers to drop in and throw money at them or they won't have anything to advertise.